BLOG

What is the difference between subjective and objective assessment in education?

We've all sat through exams, been evaluated on assignments, or even judged ourselves based on our perceptions of our own performances. But have you ever stopped to think about how these evaluations are conducted?

The two primary methods for assessment in education are subjective and objective evaluation. These methods provide the foundation for understanding and gauging a learner's understanding, abilities, and performance.

As we delve into the depths of these assessment methodologies, you'll get a clearer picture of their significance in the educational landscape. So, grab your explorer's hat, and let's embark on this enlightening journey into the world of subjective and objective evaluation in education.

Subjective Assessment: Personal Interpretations and Insights

At the heart of subjective assessment is the human element. It’s about evaluating not just the answer but the thought process behind it.

1. Varied Outcomes: The beauty of subjective assessment lies in its diversity of interpretations. For example, an essay on societal values can be approached in countless ways, and each perspective offers a fresh insight.

Recollecting my college days, I once submitted an essay on 'Modern Society and Morality'. While one professor praised it for its depth and originality, another provided feedback suggesting I could have approached it from an entirely different angle. This very incident covers the beauty and challenge of subjective evaluation.

2. Flexibility: Unlike objective assessments that look for a single correct answer, subjective evaluations cherish the spectrum of human thought. This encourages learners to explore various avenues and think outside the box. During group discussions in school, it was fascinating to see how one question could spawn a plethora of diverse, yet valid responses.

3. Complexity: Beyond just the content, subjective assessments often probe deeper into the structure, style, and presentation. They don’t merely assess what you know but how you articulate and present it.

Objective Assessment: Measured Facts and Concrete Answers

Objective assessment stands as the bastion of standardized testing, providing clear-cut answers without the haze of personal interpretation.

1. Consistency: There's comfort in consistency. With objective assessments, students can be assured that their answers, if correct, will fetch them marks irrespective of who checks it. It’s like the math problems we all tackled in school. There's a specific solution, and regardless of how we feel about it, the answer remains constant.
2. Scalability: The efficiency of objective assessments can't be stressed enough. Especially in larger settings, like nationwide examinations, where millions of answer scripts need evaluation, the clarity and speed of objective evaluation prove invaluable.
3. Clarity: Objective assessments strip away the nuances and focus on raw knowledge. This clarity is sometimes essential, especially when testing foundational concepts. Remember those pop quizzes where you either knew the answer, or you didn’t? That’s the essence of objective evaluation.

Use Cases of Subjective and Objective Evaluation in Education

In the vast realm of education, the debate between subjective and objective evaluation has been long-standing.

image alt text: subjective and objective evaluation. A teacher and a learner going through notes as a form of objective learning.

Author credit: By Alexander Pavlovsky - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=110910815

However, instead of being mutually exclusive, they are best viewed as complementary tools. Let's explore five use cases for each to understand their application in a more practical context.

Subjective Evaluation Use Cases

1. Portfolio Reviews: Art and design courses often require students to maintain portfolios showcasing their work over a semester or year. Evaluating these requires a subjective lens. It's about understanding the artist's perspective, creativity, and the evolution of their thought process.
2. Essay Writing: Essays can touch on a multitude of subjects, from societal critiques to personal reflections. The beauty of an essay lies in its individuality. Subjective evaluation here ensures the uniqueness of perspective, coherence of thought, and richness of content are all appreciated.
3. Oral Presentations: When students present topics, their understanding, articulation, and presentation style play a pivotal role. Evaluators assess not just content but also the presenter's engagement with the audience, clarity, and confidence.
4. Group Discussions: In group discussions, students interact, share perspectives, and build upon each other's thoughts. Subjective evaluation here helps in understanding a participant's communication skills, leadership, and collaborative spirit.
5. Creative Writing: Be it poetry, short stories, or plays, creative writing is deeply personal. Subjective evaluation here delves into the depth of emotion, creativity, and the originality of thought, rather than just grammatical precision.

Objective Evaluation Use Cases

1. Standardized Testing: National and international standardized tests, such as the SAT or GRE, predominantly use objective evaluation. With a vast number of students taking the test, it ensures fairness and ease of grading.
2. Pop Quizzes: Teachers might conduct short quizzes to test students' retention or understanding of a recent lesson. Objective questions like multiple-choice or true/false can quickly gauge this.
3. Entrance Examinations: For courses or institutions with a large number of applicants, objective evaluation through entrance exams ensures efficiency. It provides a quick way to sift through applicants based on a standardized knowledge threshold.
4. Periodic Assessments: In many educational systems, students undergo periodic objective assessments to test their grasp over the curriculum. This could be in the form of fill-in-the-blanks, matching columns, or single-word answers.
5. Diagnostic Tests: Often used at the beginning of courses, these tests assess the existing knowledge levels of students. Objective evaluation offers a clear snapshot of where a student stands, helping educators tailor their instruction accordingly.

Understanding when to use subjective versus objective evaluation is the key. While the former delves deep into the nuances of human thought and creativity, the latter provides a standard measure against set benchmarks.

Both are important tools in the educator's arsenal, shaping the future of learners in their unique ways.

Commonly Asked Questions

• Which is better, subjective or objective evaluation?

Neither is inherently better. The ideal assessment method depends on the goal of the evaluation. For assessing creativity or opinion, subjective might be preferable. For clear-cut knowledge checks, objective is ideal.

• Can a combination of both be used?

Absolutely! Many comprehensive assessment strategies employ both subjective and objective evaluation methods to gauge a learner's complete range of skills and knowledge.

• How do I prepare for subjective assessments?

Engage in critical thinking, understand the subject deeply, and practice expressing your understanding in various ways.

Conclusion

Subjective and objective evaluations in education are akin to the two sides of a coin, each invaluable and irreplaceable. While subjective assessments breathe life into the creative and diverse thought processes of students, objective evaluations ensure standardized knowledge and understanding across the board.

To truly appreciate the symphony of education, one must understand the harmonious blend of these assessments. They aren’t adversaries but allies, working in tandem to shape the multifaceted realm of learning and growth.